Here’s a bold statement: the world of college basketball is far more thrilling than you think, and it’s not just about the powerhouse programs. But here’s where it gets controversial—while the AP Poll continues to snub mid-majors (with Gonzaga being the lone exception), there’s a whole universe of smaller programs ready to shake things up this season. The power conferences may dominate the headlines, but every year, a handful of underdogs rise to challenge the status quo. As we gear up for another season, let’s spotlight five non-power conference teams that deserve your attention—and could very well crash the top 25.
San Diego State Aztecs
When it comes to mid-major success, the San Diego State Aztecs are the gold standard. Ranked No. 30 in the Pomeroy rankings (the highest among non-Gonzaga mid-majors), the Aztecs are a model of consistency under head coach Brian Dutcher. And this is the part most people miss—they’ve reached the NCAA tournament in each of the past five seasons, including a national championship appearance in 2023. With key starters Miles Byrd and Magoon Gwath returning after flirting with the NBA draft, this physical, defensive-minded team is poised to make noise again. Dutcher’s squad isn’t just aiming for Selection Sunday—they’re gunning for another deep run.
George Washington Revolutionaries
The George Washington Revolutionaries may not be a household name, but they’re quietly building something special. Coming off a 21-win season in the Atlantic-10, Chris Caputo’s team is flying under the radar no more. With a strong returning core and key portal additions like former Northwestern center Luke Hunger, expectations are higher than they’ve been in years. Ranked fourth in the Atlantic-10 preseason poll—their highest since 2015—this experienced roster is eyeing their first NCAA tournament berth since 2014. Here’s the question: Can they finally break through in a crowded conference?
Saint Mary’s Gaels
The Saint Mary’s Gaels are no strangers to contention in the West Coast Conference, but this year, they’re facing a major reset. After losing key players to graduation, head coach Randy Bennett has his work cut out for him. Yet, Bennett’s track record of player development speaks for itself—KenPom ranks the Gaels at No. 55 despite the roster overhaul. Known for their discipline and efficiency, the Gaels may be a mystery now, but here’s a bold prediction: don’t count them out of the NCAA tournament conversation.
Boise State Broncos
Under head coach Leon Rice, the Boise State Broncos have become the definition of consistency. With 20 or more wins in 11 of the past 14 seasons, they’re a perennial Mountain West threat. Ranked No. 53 in the KenPom preseason rankings, the Broncos return three of their top five scorers from last year’s 26-win campaign. Add in transfers like UCLA’s Dylan Andrews and Georgetown’s Drew Fielder, and this team is built to compete. The real question: Can they overcome the loss of all-time leading scorer Tyson Degenhart and stay atop the Mountain West?
South Florida Bulls
The South Florida Bulls might just be the most fascinating team on this list. With new head coach Bryan Hodgson at the helm—fresh off a successful stint at Arkansas State—the Bulls are reinventing themselves. Hodgson brought in key players from his former squad, including four-star LSU transfer center Daimion Collins, and has built a deep, intimidating roster in the American Athletic Conference. While USF lacks a storied basketball history, here’s the twist: the AAC is wide open this season, and the Bulls are primed to make a statement.
Every college basketball season brings its share of surprises, but mid-majors add a layer of unpredictability that makes the sport truly special. These programs, operating with fewer resources, consistently find ways to compete with the nation’s best. Whether we see another mid-major Final Four run like in 2023 or a season dominated by powerhouses, these smaller schools are the heartbeat of college basketball’s integrity and storytelling. So, here’s the ultimate question: Which of these teams will defy the odds and write their own Cinderella story this season? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments!
